In-house vs Outsourcing Print E-mail

Condition Monitoring Services Comparision Chart

No. Service Description On board Fleet Contract
  Service/Provision common requirements      
Data Collection      
Data collected on hand held data collectors by Ships staff Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Data collected by permanent transducers online to MIMIC Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Data collected by permanent link to control system online to MIMIC Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Periodic data back ups transmitted ashore-daily/weekly/monthly Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Upload of all ship data onto shore side server   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Provision of shore server administration     Tick/Yes
Provision of communication with ships to obtain outstanding back ups     Tick/Yes
Recognise and report faulty data collection instruments and/or incorrect data results.     Tick/Yes
Data Types      
Machinery and system process data (pressures - temperatures etc) Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Vibration monitoring with overall levels Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Vibration monitoring with FFT and time wave form Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Performance monitoring Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Logistic monitoring Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Oil analysis results Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Hydraulic fluid contamination levels Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
System Management      
MIMIC database Management required/provided Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Database Management training required/provided Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Trained data collectors Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Trained Database Users Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Trained data analysers Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Analysis of vibration data required/provided Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Analysis of process trend data required/provided Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Analysis of performance data required/provided Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Analysis of oil analysis data required/provided Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Free Software Updates Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Free Software Upgrades     Tick/Yes
Management of Fleet database required/provided   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Analysis of fleet data required/provided   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Standard Report Content      
Vibration Monitoring tours completed since last report Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Vibration Monitoring tours outstanding based against maintenance regime requirement Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Performance Monitoring tours completed since last report Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Performance Monitoring tours outstanding based against maintenance regime requirement Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Oil analysis completed since last report Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Oil analysis outstanding based against maintenance regime requirement Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
List of MIMIC alarms and warnings, recorded against each machine Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
First level diagnosis of machinery faults Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Enhanced Standard Report Content      
Maintenance rounds tasks, linked and recorded within MIMIC completed   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Maintenance rounds tasks, linked and recorded within MIMIC outstanding   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
List of Lloyd's classification requirements, in relation to monitoring, completed   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
List of Lloyd's classification requirements in relation to monitoring outstanding   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
First level diagnosis of machinery faults with suggested rectification actions   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Comparison of Fleet data results   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Fleet activity reports   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Fleet logistic reports   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Identification of inaccurate data   Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Contract Reports      
Use of report wizard to compile customised and bespoke reports. Tick/Yes Tick/Yes Tick/Yes
Analysis of vibration data in response to specific request     Tick/Yes
Publication of Performance monitoring information from standard monthly data.     Tick/Yes
Publication of Performance monitoring information in response to request from E/P IPT     Tick/Yes
Analysis of condition data, recorded across a number of platforms/ equipments to allow comparison of similar machines on similar ships     Tick/Yes
Condition reports in support of Pre Upkeep activities to support budget decisions.     Tick/Yes
Provide information for RCM reviews.     Tick/Yes
Provide information for ARM reviews and studies.     Tick/Yes
Receive vibration analysis reports in support of defect cause identification.     Tick/Yes
Compare performance data to SOAP results     Tick/Yes
Compare vibration data to SOAP results     Tick/Yes
Identify potential problems prior to ship ocean voyages.     Tick/Yes
Report on condition status of ships prior to specific tasks     Tick/Yes
Create report to support warranty/guarantee claim     Tick/Yes